So here we are (Again), August 8th. Cincinnati, Ohio. Government Square. Around 7:40 am., news broke of another police shooting. According to reports, the Jawari Porter (who had a history of mental health and was experiencing homelessness), robbed a neighborhood Kroger grocery store then made their way to a transit station an hour so later. When police arrived on the scene (Government Square), they address the Jawari, who is walking down the street, but when Jawari hears them he turns around. At this point, according to reports, the man responded to the police (there were two officers in an SUV) by asking “why, are you going to shoot me?” At this point, the turn of events go badly. The situation is unclear, but by watching the video, we see the Jawari approach the police vehicle, walk around the open door and began to strike the officer on the driver’s side. The officer on the passenger side radios a message, comes around the vehicle, grab and throw Jawari to the ground. We can only assume that this is the point where the police shot Jawari. According to reports, multiple shots were fired.
Hearing these details paint a certain picture about the situation and the people involved. It also brings up a lot of questions. Should suspects with a history of mental illness be treated differently than any other suspect? If the suspect had a known history of mental illness, why wasn’t a professional with specific experience on the scene? Should officers interact differently with people who suffer from mental illness. Should officers arrive on the approach suspects with their weapons ready? Is the use of deadly force ever an effective, humane solution? Why are there so many of these videos?
Depending on your politics, you may have an answer for most of these questions. For the rest of us, the answers to these questions are hard to figure out. Why? Because many of these decisions are subjective/dependent on the situation. Some of us like myself have many people in my life who with mental illness. We understand that sometimes you have to change your strategy when dealing with mental illness. We both know that it takes a special person to effectively deescalate this population. My mother is a home group home administrator for people with cognitive disabilities. She has been in this business for over twenty years. Some of my first memories interacting with adults involve me sitting down with Mirna (name changed obviously) and her sharing the stories of Special Olympic gold medals (they were for bowling, soft ball throw, and 50 meter dash), Micheal Jackson albums, and government sanctioned forced sterilization of people with mental health issues (yeah we did that, maybe we still do).
We live in a society full of addictions, hate rhetoric, overt and subversive kyriarchy, distrust and fear. All of these things cause psychological trauma. They affect us everyday and some of us don’t realize it. They create the need to steal to survive. They create officers who are trigger happy. They create citizens who can hear about a police shooting and turn on Finding Nemo in one motion. We need to acknowledge that issues of oppression hurts everyone. We need to ackn0wledge that systematic violence has made us both numb and engaged. Mental health needs to be acknowledged. That doesn’t mean we should only focus on reactive solutions, but preventative solutions also. How can we ensure everyone has support for their mental health needs before an emergency arises?
We know we have legislation for people with disabilities (Americans with Disabilities Act). But, we need to push it further. We need to ensure that all public officials are required to get competency training for working with special populations. There should also be a mental health trained officer on every beat. I am not saying the situation would have ended differently, but perhaps a trained professional would have approached an agitated person with mental health differently (without the gun drawn in a calm manner). My suppositions aren’t as important as my message. In order to stop violence, we have to be willing to quit using violence to enforce the law. They say you get out of life what you put in to it. So if you put in oppression, what do you expect to get out of it.
Resources:
Commonly Asked Questions About the Americans with Disabilities Act and Law Enforcement
Interacting with Law Enforcement: A Guide for Persons with Disabilities –










